Buying Guides.

The Best Spirits We Tasted in October

Some spirits blew our tasters away in all the right ways in October, including a 99-pointer.

/ By Alex Martin

The Best Spirits We Tasted in October
Ardbeg concluded its Y2K series in October / ©Ardbeg

October's tastings made room for some standout rums, with three aged variations making their way into the month's top ten.

Expressions from Hampden Estate, Appleton Estate, and the oldest rum ever released by Foursquare join tequilas, Scotch whiskies, and bourbons in this month’s eclectic selection.

Take a look at this month’s highest scores, and don’t forget to check out all our reviews from October on Tasting Notes.

Ola, Missouri Oak Aged Okolehao

Ola Brew is reviving ʻōkolehao, the traditional Hawaiian spirit made from kī, or ti plant, root, and this Missouri Oak Aged expression is its sipping version, bottled at 41%.

Ola grows its own kī on a 40-acre farm, and the spirit will be sold only in Hawaiʻi for at least the next two years.

Our taster Brad Japhe found “an earthy bouquet” of taro root and wet slate, followed by “a tropical fruit basket of unripened banana and cinnamon-dusted passion fruit.”

Okolehao

Ola, Missouri Oak Aged Okolehao

Brand name
Ola Distillery
ABV
41%
Region, Country
United States
90
img

Seelbach’s Private Reserve, Usonia Mizunara

Released in October 2026, Usonia is the first release of Seelbach’s Usonia Mizunara Bourbon, a blend of four nine-year-old Kentucky straight bourbons finished for five months in two lightly toasted Japanese Mizunara barrels and bottled at 58.8%. Just 496 bottles were made.

Brad Japhe called it “an outlier in the category,” trading the usual maple syrup and vanilla for “a savory exultation of dried, earthy spice”: tobacco, black tea and barbecued brisket.

American Whiskey

Seelbach’s Private Reserve, Usonia Mizunara

Brand name
Seelbach’s
Subcategory
Bourbon
ABV
58.8%
Region, Country
Kentucky, United States
90
img

The Macallan, Horizon

Announced in March 2024, The Macallan Horizon was the first release created with Bentley Motors, issued in the distillery’s 200th anniversary year.

Master whisky maker Kirsteen Campbell chose six first-fill sherry-seasoned oak casks, and the 46.6% ABV bottling strength is a nod to both the casks and The Macallan’s Six Pillars.

Joel Harrison found “a distinctly grown-up character,” despite the non-age statement, with “polished wood, leather armchairs” on the nose and a finish that is “long and gently bittersweet.”

Scotch

The Macallan, Horizon

Brand name
The Macallan
Subcategory
Single Malt
ABV
46.6%
Region, Country
Speyside, Scotland
91
img

Old Fitzgerald, Bottled-in-Bond Spring 2026

Announced in June 2026 and reaching US shelves from July, the Spring 2026 Old Fitzgerald Decanter Series is the seventeenth national edition in the series.

It is a 10-year-old bottled-in-bond Kentucky straight bourbon, distilled in Spring 2016 and bottled at 50% in Spring 2026.

Brad Japhe called it “a surprisingly gentle dram,” with “crème brûlée and antique oak varnish” on the nose and a palate of butterscotch and brioche “dipped in vanilla frosting.”

American Whiskey

Old Fitzgerald, Bottled-in-Bond Spring 2026

Brand name
Old Fitzgerald
Subcategory
Bourbon
ABV
50%
Region, Country
Kentucky, United States
92
img

Tapatio, Blanco 110

Tapatio Blanco 110 is the high-proof blanco from Carlos Camarena’s La Alteña distillery in Los Altos, Jalisco. It’s made from estate-grown agave and distilled close to bottle strength after being crushed with a tahona and roller mill, naturally fermented and unaged.

Our taster Millie Milliken found a nose that is “beautifully earthy, with petrichor,” a palate that is “oily and mouth-filling,” and “that tell-tale black pepper character” on the finish.

Tequila

Tapatio, Blanco 110

Brand name
Tapatio
Subcategory
Blanco (Silver)
ABV
55%
Region, Country
Jalisco, Mexico
94
img

ArteNOM, Selección de 1123 Blanco

ArteNOM’s Selección de 1123 Blanco comes from the family-run Cascahuín in El Arenal, Jalisco, and is the brainchild of master distiller Salvador “Chava” Rosales Torres.

Using valley agave roasted in stone ovens, it rests for 21 to 28 days in casks that previously held Oaxacan mezcal and is bottled at 43%.

Millie Milliken found “petrichor” and “crunchy fresh parsley leaves and stalks” on the nose, then a palate that is “surprisingly creamy and cooling at the same time.”

Tequila

ArteNom, Selección de 1123 Blanco

Brand name
ArteNom
Subcategory
Blanco (Silver)
ABV
43%
Region, Country
Jalisco, Mexico
95
img

Ardbeg, Vintage_Y2K 25 Years Old

Announced in September 2026, Vintage_Y2K 25 Years Old is the third and final release in Ardbeg’s millennium series, and its oldest and rarest.

Made with spirit from a still the distillery retired in 2001, it was matured in bourbon casks, finished in Tempranillo wine casks from Spain’s Bodega Numanthia, and bottled at 48% ABV.

Neil Ridley called it “a landmark for the distillery,” with “rich dark chocolate, spices galore” and “a waft of smokiness that tells you all you need to know about the past quarter of a century.”

Scotch

Arbeg, Y2K 25 Year Old

Brand name
Ardbeg
Subcategory
Single Malt
ABV
48%
Region, Country
Islay, Scotland
96
img

The Last Drop, Signature Creation by Richard Seale

Released in October 2026 as The Last Drop’s 43rd release, this release is the independent bottler’s first rum under its Signature Creation label, and the oldest rum Foursquare has released.

The creator is Richard Seale, a fourth-generation rum distiller and owner of Foursquare rum. It was aged for 22 years in different cask types, then moved into port pipes, and finally bottled at 53% ABV.

Neil Ridley called it “a truly landmark rum,” “vibrant, powerful and yet elegant at the same time,” with “a swathe of tropical fruit” that appears long after the first sip.

Rum

The Last Drop, Signature Creation by Richard Seale

Brand name
Foursquare
Subcategory
Aged
ABV
53%
Region, Country
Barbados
97
img

Appleton Estate, Hearts Collection 1999

Appleton Estate’s Hearts Collection 1999 returns after five more years in cask, moving from its earlier 21-year-old bottling to 26 years old.

Drawn from ten ex-bourbon casks, distilled on a Forsyth pot still and aged entirely in Jamaica, it was bottled in 2025 at 63% ABV, with 1,406 bottles available worldwide.

Brad Japhe was impressed. He found “dark roast coffee and dried mango” on the nose, and “a brilliant balancing act between funky distillate and expertly extracted wood sugars.”

Rum

Appleton Estate, Hearts Collection 1999

Brand name
Appleton Estate
Subcategory
Aged
ABV
63%
Region, Country
Jamaica
98
img

Hampden Estate, 15 Year Old

Hampden Estate 15 Year Old debuted in 2025 at Whisky Live Paris before joining Hampden’s core range in March 2026.

It is the Jamaican distillery’s oldest expression, aged for 15 years in ex-bourbon casks in the island’s heat and humidity, and bottled at 50% ABV.

Brad Japhe found “pungent odors of overripe tropical fruit,” giving way to clove-studded pineapple and dried mango, and a finish that “sticks the landing” with grilled tropical fruit.

Rum

Hampden Estate, 15 Year Old

Brand name
Hampden Estate
Subcategory
Aged
ABV
50%
Region, Country
Jamaica
99
img

Related Articles

Websites in our network