American Whiskey

Eagle Rare, 25 Year Old

Brand Name
Buffalo Trace
Subcategory
Bourbon
Region, Country
Kentucky, United States
ABV
50.5%
Age
25 years
img
Rating
94

The oldest Eagle Rare ever upon release, this 25 Year Old was limited to just 200 bottles. Aged in new American oak, the whiskey pushed the practical limits of bourbon maturation, where climate and cask interaction accelerate ageing far faster than in Scotch. Part of a long-term experimental programme, the bourbon spent its final years in the distillery’s temperature- and humidity-controlled Warehouse P. The result demonstrated a carefully managed approach to extended ageing, balancing oak influence with depth, maturity and complexity at an age rarely achieved in Kentucky.

Nose

Butterscotch, vanilla, black cherry jam, peanut brittle, dark chocolate

Palate

Vanilla fudge, oak spice, pencil shavings, black pepper

Finish

Oak spice, worn leather, dark chocolate

The nose is layered with butterscotch, vanilla and a richer sweetness of black cherry jam and peanut brittle, while deeper aromas of oak and dark chocolate sit underneath. The palate stays surprisingly light, carrying vanilla fudge before the oak grows more assertive with leather, pencil shavings and black pepper. The finish leans heavily into oak yet avoids drying out, and a splash of water lifts the spice into a warm, steady burn.

Alex Martin
Score
94

Style

4
Body
4
Richness
0
Smoke
3
Sweetness

Details

Company
Bottler
Bottle size
0.75L
No of bottles
200
Cask Influence
Bottling date
2023
Cask strength
Chill-Filtered
Natural colour
Yes
Additives
No
img
94
American Whiskey

Eagle Rare, 25 Year Old

Brand name
Buffalo Trace
Subcategory
Bourbon
Region, Country
Kentucky, United States
Websites in our network